Note to users. If you're seeing this message, it means that your browser cannot find this page's style/presentation instructions -- or possibly that you are using a browser that does not support current Web standards. Find out more about why this message is appearing, and what you can do to make your experience of our site the best it can be.
Negative Regulation of Toll-Like Receptor Signaling by NF-B p50 Ubiquitination Blockade
Ruaidhrí J. Carmody,
Qingguo Ruan,
Scott Palmer,
Brendan Hilliard,
Youhai H. Chen*
Abstract:
Toll-like receptors (TLRs) trigger the production of inflammatorycytokines and shape adaptive and innate immunity to pathogens.We report the identification of B cell leukemia (Bcl)–3as an essential negative regulator of TLR signaling. By blockingubiquitination of p50, a member of the nuclear factor (NF)-Bfamily, Bcl-3 stabilizes a p50 complex that inhibits gene transcription.As a consequence, Bcl-3–deficient mice and cells werefound to be hypersensitive to TLR activation and unable to controlresponses to lipopolysaccharides. Thus, p50 ubiquitination blockadeby Bcl-3 limits the strength of TLR responses and maintainsinnate immune homeostasis. These findings indicate that thep50 ubiquitination pathway can be selectively targeted to controldeleterious inflammatory diseases.
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA.
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: yhc{at}mail.med.upenn.edu
Toll-like receptor (TLR) activation is essential for the developmentof innate immunity to pathogens (1, 2). However, repeated orprolonged activation of TLRs can render them insensitive orhyporesponsive to subsequent ligand stimulation. This phenomenonis referred to as TLR tolerance (3). The molecular mechanismsof TLR tolerance are not well understood, although several negativeregulators of TLR signaling have been implicated (4–10).Bcl-3 is a nuclear member of the inhibitor of NF-B (IB) family,which interacts exclusively with the transcriptionally inactivehomodimers of p50 and p52, two members of the NF-B family (11–13).Bcl3 deficiency in mice disrupts the microarchitecture of lymphoidorgans but does not affect the development of lymphoid or myeloidcells (14, 15). To explore the roles of Bcl-3 in immunity andtolerance, we examined the phenotype and function of Bcl3-deficientcells. We found that, although Bcl3 deficiency did not affectcell surface marker expression or phagocytotic function (fig.S1), Bcl3–/– macrophages, dendritic cells, and Bcells produced significantly more cytokines than wild-type (WT)cells upon stimulation with several TLR ligands (Fig. 1 andfigs. S2 and S3). Additionally, Bcl3–/– macrophageswere also hypersensitive to interleukin (IL)-1ß andtumor necrosis factor (TNF)– stimulation (fig. S3).
Fig. 1.. Bcl-3 inhibits cytokine gene expression and controls NF-B dimer exchange at gene promoters. (A) Bcl3–/– macrophages are hyperresponsive to LPS. Bone marrow–derived (BMD) macrophages were stimulated with LPS, and cytokine mRNA was quantified by real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) (25). Error bars indicate ±SEM. (B) Bcl3–/– dendritic cells are hyperresponsive to LPS. BMD dendritic cells were stimulated with LPS, and gene expression was measured by real-time PCR. (C) Enhanced proliferation of Bcl3–/– B cells to LPS. Splenic B cells were stimulated with LPS, and 3H-thymidine incorporation was measured as count per minute (cpm). (D) Enhanced gene expression in Bcl3–/– B cells. B cells were stimulated with LPS, and TNF gene expression was measured by real-time PCR. (E) Bcl3–/– macrophages have reduced p50 DNA binding. Nuclear extracts from BMD macrophages were tested by EMSA with the consensus NF-B–binding sequence and indicated antibodies. Arrow indicates p50 complexes. (F) Altered NF-B dimer loading and exchange at gene promoters in Bcl3–/– macrophages. BMD macrophages were treated with LPS, and ChIP was performed with antibodies to the indicated factors.
[View Larger Version of this Image (51K GIF file)]
The hyperresponsiveness of Bcl3–/– cells was notdue to increased receptor-proximal signaling (fig. S4A) butcould be blocked by a NF-B inhibitor (fig. S3F). In responseto lipopolysaccharides (LPS), Bcl3–/– cells displayeda marked reduction in nuclear p50 DNA binding relative to WTcontrols (Fig. 1E), although nuclear translocations of p50,p65, and c-Rel were normal (fig. S4B). Chromatin immunoprecipitation(ChIP) analysis revealed a similar reduction in p50 bindingto promoters of TNF and CXCL2 (chemokine C-X-C motif ligand2) genes in Bcl3–/– cells (Fig. 1F). In unstimulatedWT macrophages, TNF and CXCL2 promoters contained only the p50subunit of NF-B, indicating the presence of p50 homodimer binding.After stimulation with LPS, p50 was transiently replaced byc-Rel and p65 dimers (Fig. 1F). Five hours after stimulation,both TNF and CXCL2 promoters reverted to the state of p50 occupancy(Fig. 1F). In contrast, unstimulated Bcl3–/– macrophageslacked p50 homodimers on the TNF and CXCL2 promoters, whichwere instead occupied by p65, c-Rel, and p50 dimers (Fig. 1F).The order of p65 and c-Rel dimer exchange on both TNF and CXCL2promoters was severely disrupted in LPS-stimulated Bcl3–/–cells (Fig. 1F), indicating an essential role for Bcl-3 andp50 homodimers in regulating NF-B DNA binding and transcriptionaloutput of target genes.
Although Bcl-3 has previously been reported to enhance p50 homodimerDNA binding (16, 17), the established picomolar dissociationconstant of p50 homodimers suggests that any further increasein their affinity is unlikely to be significant (18, 19). Insupport of this, we observed no measurable differences in thebinding affinity of p50 homodimers in the presence or absenceof overexpressed Bcl-3 despite a clear increase in p50 DNA bindingin cells overexpressing Bcl-3 (Fig. 2A). Overexpressing Bcl-3increased p50 protein levels in a dose-dependent manner, leadingto increased p50 DNA binding, as shown in an electrophoreticmobility shift assay (EMSA) (Fig. 2B). Pulse chase analysisdemonstrated that the half-life of p50 protein (57 min) wasalmost doubled in cells overexpressing Bcl-3 (93 min) (Fig. 2C).These results indicate that Bcl-3 increases p50 DNA bindingby extending the half-life of p50 rather than by enhancing itsaffinity to DNA.
Fig. 2.. Bcl-3 inhibits p50 ubiquitination and degradation. (A) Bcl-3 increases p50 homodimer binding to DNA without altering its affinity. Human embryonic kidney (HEK) 293T cells were transfected with p50 and Bcl-3 expression plasmids. EMSA was performed with increasing amounts of unlabeled NF-B consensus oligonucleotides (cold probe) (left), and p50 homodimer DNA binding was measured by densitometry (middle). Relative protein levels were determined by immunoblotting of whole-cell extracts (right). WB, Western blot. (B) Increased p50 homodimer DNA binding is associated with increased amounts of p50 protein. HEK 293T cells were transfected with XP-p50 and increasing amounts of myc-Bcl-3 plasmids. p50 and Bcl-3 levels were measured in whole-cell lysates by immunoblotting (top), and p50 homodimer DNA binding was measured by EMSA (bottom). Empty, empty vector alone. (C) Bcl-3 increases the half-life of p50. HEK 293T cells were cotransfected with XP-p50 and empty vector or myc-Bcl-3, and the half-life (t1/2) of proteins was determined (25). IP, immunoprecipitation. (D) p50 undergoes Lys48 (K48) polyubiquitination. HEK 293T cells were transfected with XP-p50 and expression vectors encoding either WT, Lys48Arg48 (K48R) mutant, Lys63Arg63 (K63R) mutant, or lysine-less (KØ) HA-tagged ubiquitin (Ub). Lysates were immunoprecipitated with antibody against XP and immunoblotted with antibody against HA. (E) Bcl-3 inhibits p50 ubiquitination. HEK 293T cells were transfected with XP-p50 and HA-ubiquitin with or without myc-Bcl-3. Ubiquitination was determined as in (D).
[View Larger Version of this Image (41K GIF file)]
To determine the potential roles of Lys48-mediated ubiquitinationpathway in the turnover of p50 homodimers, we examined the polyubiquitinationof both overexpressed and endogenous p50. Overexpressed p50underwent constitutive Lys48-mediated polyubiquitination, whichwas dramatically inhibited by Bcl-3 (Fig. 2E). Significant ubiquitinationof endogenous p50 was detected only after LPS stimulation, whichwas markedly increased in Bcl3–/– macrophages (Fig. 3A).The increased ubiquitination of p50 in Bcl3–/– cellsled to a fourfold reduction in its half-life (63 min versus240 min in WT cells) (Fig. 3B). Importantly, Bcl3 deficiencydid not affect the half-life of p65, c-Rel, or the p50 precursor,p105. Mutation of Tyr57 and Gly60 in the DNA binding domainof p50 (20) gave rise to a DNA binding–defective mutant,p50Y57A,G60D, that was unable to bind to DNA (Fig. 3C) but retainedthe ability to interact with p65 and Bcl-3 (fig. S5). Ubiquitinationof p50Y57A,G60D was dramatically reduced compared with thatof WT p50 (Fig. 3D). This was associated with a significantincrease in p50Y57A,G60D half-life (Fig. 3E). Taken together,these results establish that p50 homodimer binding to DNA triggersits polyubiquitination and degradation, which are effectivelyblocked by Bcl-3.
Fig. 3..Bcl3–/– macrophages have increased p50 ubiquitination and degradation. (A) Increased ubiquitination of p50 in Bcl3–/– macrophages. BMD macrophages were treated with (+) or without (–) LPS for 16 hours. Equal amounts of protein were immunoprecipitated with antibody against p50 and immunoblotted with antibody against ubiquitin. (B) Reduced p50 half-life in Bcl3–/– macrophages. BMD macrophages were treated with LPS, pulse-labeled with 35S-methionine cysteine, and tested as in Fig. 2C. (C) Generation of a p50 mutant that does not bind to DNA. HEK 293T cells were transfected with XP-p50 or an XP-p50 mutant containing Lys57Ala57 (Y57A) and Gly60Asp60 (G60D) substitutions in the DNA binding domain. EMSA was performed with the consensus NF-B binding sequence. (D) The p50 mutant is resistant to ubiquitination. Cells were transfected with HA-ubiquitin plus XP-p50, XP-p50Y57A,G60D, or empty vector. Ubiquitination was determined as in Fig. 2D. (E) The p50 mutant has a significantly increased half-life. HEK 293T cells were co-transfected with XP-p50 or XP-p50Y57A,G60D, and protein half-life was determined (25).
[View Larger Version of this Image (38K GIF file)]
We next examined whether Bcl-3 played a role in TLR tolerance,because p50 homodimers have previously been implicated in thisprocess (21). WT and Bcl3–/– macrophages were treatedwith LPS for 24 hours (to induce tolerance), rested, and restimulatedwith LPS. Pretreatment of WT cells with LPS induced tolerance,characterized by reduced cytokine gene expression upon restimulation(Fig. 4A). By contrast, LPS pretreatment of Bcl3–/–macrophages not only failed to repress cytokine gene expressionbut significantly increased IL6 and CCL2 expression upon restimulation(Fig. 4A). Bcl3 deficiency did not significantly alter the expressionof other negative regulators of TLRs or receptor-proximal signalsin tolerized cells (fig. S6). However, like IRAK-M (IL-1 receptor–associatedkinase-M), SOCS-1 (suppressor of cytokine signaling 1), andA20, Bcl-3 was significantly up-regulated in tolerized macrophages(fig. S6). As expected, Bcl-3 knockdown by RNA interferencediminished LPS tolerance (fig. S7), whereas Bcl-3 overexpressionsignificantly inhibited TNF promoter activity (fig. S8). Re-stimulationof tolerized WT macrophages with LPS led to p50 homodimer bindingto the TNF promoter, whereas in Bcl3–/– macrophagesrestimulation led to p65 dimer binding (Fig. 4B). Thus, Bcl-3mediates LPS tolerance by stabilizing the p50 homodimer on theTNF promoter and by preventing the binding of transcriptionallyactive p65 dimer.
Fig. 4..Bcl3 deficiency in mice and macrophages abolishes LPS tolerance. (A) Lack of LPS tolerance in Bcl3–/– macrophages. BMD macrophages were pretreated with (+) or without (–) LPS for 24 hours. After 1 hour of resting, cells were restimulated with LPS for an additional hour. mRNA levels were determined by real-time PCR. (B) Reduced p50 homodimer binding to TNF promoter in Bcl3–/– macrophages under tolerizing conditions. BMD macrophages were treated as in (A). ChIP was performed with antibodies to p50, p65, and c-Rel. (C) Bcl3 deficiency in hematopoietic cells renders mice hypersensitive to septic shock. WT mice were lethally irradiated and reconstituted with either WT or Bcl3–/– bone marrow (BM) cells (n from 3 to 5) (25). Eight weeks later, chimeric mice were tolerized with two consecutive injections of low dose LPS (5 mg/kg on day –5 and 10 mg/kg on day –3) and then challenged with three high doses of LPS (15 mg/kg on day 0, 30 mg/kg on day 6, and 90 mg/kg on day 9 as indicated by arrows). Data shown are survival curves of the two groups. The difference between the two groups is statistically significant (P < 0.01). Error bars indicate ± SEM.
[View Larger Version of this Image (38K GIF file)]
To determine the roles of Bcl-3 in vivo, we studied TLR tolerancein bone marrow chimeric mice that did or did not express Bcl-3in their hematopoietic cells. Mice were first tolerized withlow doses of LPS and challenged with increasing doses of LPS.LPS pretreatment protected all mice that received WT bone marrowfrom septic shock. By contrast, the vast majority of mice thatreceived Bcl3–/– bone marrow died of the diseasea few days after LPS challenge (Fig. 4C).
Taken together, these results establish that Bcl-3 promotesp50 homodimer occupancy of target gene promoters by inhibitingthe ubiquitination and subsequent degradation of DNA-bound p50homodimers. We propose that this state of Bcl-3-p50 homodimer-mediatedpromoter hyporesponsiveness is the molecular basis of TLR tolerance.Neither Bcl-3 nor p50 alone is sufficient to maintain the tolerantstate of gene promoters (Fig. 4) (22). In the absence of Bcl-3-p50complex, the loading of NF-B subunits on target promoters andthe subsequent dimer exchange, critical for appropriate geneexpression (23, 24), are disrupted, leading to aberrant expressionof inflammatory cytokines. Thus, TLR tolerance and suppressionare dependent on the coordinated action of both the inhibitorp50 and its stabilizer, Bcl-3 (fig. S9 and SOM text). Thesefindings provide important insights into the molecular mechanismsof TLR signaling and suggest that deleterious inflammatory responsescan be effectively controlled by targeting the NF-B p50 ubiquitinationpathway.
Materials and methods are available as supporting material on Science Online.
The authors thank K. Keeshan, M. May, and X. Yang for valuable discussion and critical evaluation of this work and M. Walsh for providing hemagglutinin (HA)-ubiquitin and its mutants. This work was supported by grants from the NIH (AI50059, DK070691, and AI069289).
Received for publication 23 March 2007. Accepted for publication 27 June 2007.
The editors suggest the following Related Resources on Science sites:
In Science Magazine
INTRODUCTION TO SPECIAL ISSUE
Stephen J. Simpson and John Travis (3 August 2007) Science317 (5838), 611.
[DOI: 10.1126/science.317.5838.611] |Summary »|PDF »
In Science Signaling
EDITORS' CHOICE
Stephen J. Simpson (7 August 2007) Sci. STKE2007 (398), tw286.
[DOI: 10.1126/stke.3982007tw286] |Abstract »
THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN CITED BY OTHER ARTICLES:
Dissociation of Endotoxin Tolerance and Differentiation of Alternatively Activated Macrophages.
R. Rajaiah, D. J. Perkins, S. K. Polumuri, A. Zhao, A. D. Keegan, and S. N. Vogel (2013)
J. Immunol.
190, 4763-4772
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Sonic hedgehog-Dependent Induction of MicroRNA 31 and MicroRNA 150 Regulates Mycobacterium bovis BCG-Driven Toll-Like Receptor 2 Signaling.
D. S. Ghorpade, S. Holla, S. V. Kaveri, J. Bayry, S. A. Patil, and K. N. Balaji (2013)
Mol. Cell. Biol.
33, 543-556
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Critical Roles of Glucocorticoid-Induced Leucine Zipper in Infectious Bursal Disease Virus (IBDV)-Induced Suppression of Type I Interferon Expression and Enhancement of IBDV Growth in Host Cells via Interaction with VP4.
Z. Li, Y. Wang, X. Li, X. Li, H. Cao, and S. J. Zheng (2013)
J. Virol.
87, 1221-1231
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Deubiquitination of NF-{kappa}B by Ubiquitin-Specific Protease-7 promotes transcription.
A. Colleran, P. E. Collins, C. O'Carroll, A. Ahmed, X. Mao, B. McManus, P. A. Kiely, E. Burstein, and R. J. Carmody (2013)
PNAS
110, 618-623
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Induction of Bcl-3 by acute binge alcohol results in Toll-like receptor 4/LPS tolerance.
S. Bala, A. Tang, D. Catalano, J. Petrasek, O. Taha, K. Kodys, and G. Szabo (2012)
J. Leukoc. Biol.
92, 611-620
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Nuclear factor-{kappa}B binding motifs specify Toll-like receptor-induced gene repression through an inducible repressosome.
Q. Yan, R. J. Carmody, Z. Qu, Q. Ruan, J. Jager, S. E. Mullican, M. A. Lazar, and Y. H. Chen (2012)
PNAS
109, 14140-14145
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
NF-{kappa}B, the first quarter-century: remarkable progress and outstanding questions.
Roles of Bcl-3 in the Pathogenesis of Murine Type 1 Diabetes.
Q. Ruan, S.-J. Zheng, S. Palmer, R. J. Carmody, and Y. H. Chen (2010)
Diabetes
59, 2549-2557
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
The Repressing Function of the Oncoprotein BCL-3 Requires CtBP, while Its Polyubiquitination and Degradation Involve the E3 Ligase TBLR1.
A. Keutgens, K. Shostak, P. Close, X. Zhang, B. Hennuy, M. Aussems, J.-P. Chapelle, P. Viatour, A. Gothot, M. Fillet, et al. (2010)
Mol. Cell. Biol.
30, 4006-4021
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
I{kappa}B{eta}, a nuclear I{kappa}B protein, positively regulates the NF-{kappa}B-mediated expression of proinflammatory cytokines.
Immediate mediators of the inflammatory response are poised for gene activation through RNA polymerase II stalling.
K. Adelman, M. A. Kennedy, S. Nechaev, D. A. Gilchrist, G. W. Muse, Y. Chinenov, and I. Rogatsky (2009)
PNAS
106, 18207-18212
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Tumor Necrosis Factor-{alpha} Induces RelA Degradation via Ubiquitination at Lysine 195 to Prevent Excessive Nuclear Factor-{kappa}B Activation.
Y. Fan, R. Mao, Y. Zhao, Y. Yu, W. Sun, P. Song, Z. Shi, D. Zhang, E. Yvon, H. Zhang, et al. (2009)
J. Biol. Chem.
284, 29290-29297
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Specification of DNA Binding Activity of NF-{kappa}B Proteins.
The NF-{kappa}B Family of Transcription Factors and Its Regulation.
A. Oeckinghaus and S. Ghosh (2009)
Cold Spring Harb Perspect Biol
1, a000034
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Validation-based insertional mutagenesis identifies lysine demethylase FBXL11 as a negative regulator of NF{kappa}B.
T. Lu, M. W. Jackson, A. D. Singhi, E. S. Kandel, M. Yang, Y. Zhang, A. V. Gudkov, and G. R. Stark (2009)
PNAS
106, 16339-16344
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Impaired M. tuberculosis-mediated apoptosis in alveolar macrophages from HIV+ persons: potential role of IL-10 and BCL-3.
N. R. Patel, K. Swan, X. Li, S. D. Tachado, and H. Koziel (2009)
J. Leukoc. Biol.
86, 53-60
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Differential NF-{kappa}B pathways induction by Lactobacillus plantarum in the duodenum of healthy humans correlating with immune tolerance.
P. van Baarlen, F. J. Troost, S. van Hemert, C. van der Meer, W. M. de Vos, P. J. de Groot, G. J. E. J. Hooiveld, R.-J. M. Brummer, and M. Kleerebezem (2009)
PNAS
106, 2371-2376
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
Dendritic Cells and Monocyte/Macrophages That Create the IL-6/APRIL-Rich Lymph Node Microenvironments Where Plasmablasts Mature.
E. Mohr, K. Serre, R. A. Manz, A. F. Cunningham, M. Khan, D. L. Hardie, R. Bird, and I. C. M. MacLennan (2009)
J. Immunol.
182, 2113-2123
|Abstract »|Full Text »|PDF »
The Proto-Oncogene Bcl3, Induced by Tax, Represses Tax-Mediated Transcription via p300 Displacement from the Human T-Cell Leukemia Virus Type 1 Promoter.