Note to users. If you're seeing this message, it means that your browser cannot find this page's style/presentation instructions -- or possibly that you are using a browser that does not support current Web standards. Find out more about why this message is appearing, and what you can do to make your experience of our site the best it can be.

E-Conference: Defining Calcium Entry Signals

Post a Response Save to My Folders

How many stores are there?

11 June 2004

Michael Berridge

Reinholt Penner

Reinholt, there is no doubt that the system is complex but one has to start with a "simplistic interpretation" to create a robust working hypothesis that attempts to bring together most of the salient observations. The main object of my working hypothesis was to describe a mechanism of Ca2+ entry and then to explain how it might function in the development of a typical Ca2+ transient. Many of the points that you made seemed to me to be exactly in line with this hypothesis except for two points. Firstly, you propose the existence of two stores, the CRAC store and the much larger release store and I shall discuss this later. Secondly, you do not mention the role for lumenal Ca2+, which I consider as an important component of the hypothesis in that it sets the sensitivity of IP3Rs. With these two points in mind, let me comment on your three points:

  1. This point about the action of very low subthreshold doses is well taken. I very much like your observation that CRAC can be activated at 30nM carbachol without inducing release, has this been published? An essential component of my hypothesis is that entry occurs before release and I suggested a possible mechanism for this in my hypothesis. I suggested that the formation of IP3 was highly localized in the immediate vicinity of the receptor, exactly as you do, where it could have two possible actions. Either it could activate conformation coupling directly or it could induce a local release to switch on entry through local store emptying.
  2. You make a distinction between subthreshold and threshold on the basis that the latter is the concentration that begins to give a meaningful Ca2+ signal in the form of a Ca2+ spike, which relates to a point made by Ken Byron. I am comfortable with this distinction because it fits in very nicely with my hypothesis. The two are really part of a continuum. At the subthreshold dose the entry is not large enough to set up the conditions for release to occur for two reasons. Firstly the level of IP3 reaching the uncoupled receptors is not high enough to trigger them. Secondly, and more importantly, the level of entry is not large enough to increase the lumenal level of Ca2+ sufficiently to sensitize the uncoupled IP3Rs to the low level of IP3.
  3. You seem to be concerned about why there is no plateau phase during this threshold condition. As I argued before, the reason why there is no plateau phase is because the SERCA pumps are very efficient at taking up the Ca2+ and it this uptake that sensitizes the IP3Rs.

  4. With regard to high doses, I agree with you completely.

Perhaps the main difference in our interpretation is whether there is a single or two separate stores (a CRAC store and a larger release store). I dealt with this question in my comments. It seems that we both agree that there has to be two functional stores and the question therefore is whether or not they are physically separate. I argue that the ER is continuous but that it can be separated physiologically into two regions. The junctional zone that responds to the high dose of IP3 near the membrane and the remainder of the store where the uncoupled IP3Rs are located. At physiological agonist concentrations, these uncoupled receptors do not respond directly to IP3 because the concentration is too low. Therefore, before they can respond to the low ambient IP3 level they have to be sensitized by the Ca2+ coming in from the outside through the entry pathway.

As I mentioned in my comments, the problem with having two separate stores is what happens when the small CRAC store fills up and the main release pool is still empty?

Post a Response Save to My Folders

To Advertise     Find Products

Science Signaling. ISSN 1937-9145 (online), 1945-0877 (print). Pre-2008: Science's STKE. ISSN 1525-8882